Decision Loops: How Top Leaders Make Faster, Better Decisions

Ever notice how some executives seem to make decisions with remarkable speed and confidence, while others get stuck in analysis paralysis?

What if I told you the difference isn’t intelligence or experience, but a systematic approach most aren’t taught?

It’s something I call "the Decision Loop, and it’s transforming how the most effective leaders navigate complexity.

The Hidden Cost of Decision Delays

For many leaders in your position, the math is brutal:

Every day a decision sits unmade is costing you - in missed opportunities, in team momentum, and competitive advantage.

Yet, rushing decisions can be equally disastrous.

This is especially true when you’re trying to build a leadership pipeline. When your managers see you stuck in decision limbo, they model that same behavior with their teams.

The result? A cascading effect of organizational paralysis.

The Decision Loop Method

After working with hundreds of leaders scaling companies from 100 to 1000+ employees, I’ve observed a pattern among those who consistently make effective decisions:

They use a framework I call the Decision Loop.

Here’s how it works:

1. Classify the Decision

Before anything else, top leaders immediately categorize decisions into three buckets:

• Type 1: Irreversible decisions (hire/fire, major investments)
• Type 2: Reversible decisions with significant impact
• Type 3: Easily reversible decisions with limited consequences

The classification determines everything that follows.

2. Right-Size Your Process

For each type:

• Type 1: Requires deep analysis, multiple perspectives, and careful consideration
• Type 2: Needs clear parameters and rapid testing
• Type 3: Delegate or decide quickly with minimal analysis

Most executives make the costly mistake of applying a Type 1 process to Type 3 decisions, creating bottlenecks that strangle organizational progress.

3. Set the Decision Timer

For each decision type, establish a clear deadline:

• Type 1: Days or weeks (but never open-ended)
• Type 2: Hours to days
• Type 3: Minutes to hours

When Sammy, a manufacturing VP I worked with, implemented decision timers, the decision velocity of her management team nearly doubled.

This had an immediate impact on project completion rates.

4. Create Feedback Loops

The most powerful part: For Type 2 and 3 decisions, establish how you’ll measure success and when you’ll evaluate.

This transforms potentially risky decisions into learning opportunities.

Put This Into Practice This Week

Here’s your immediate action plan:

1. Identify three pending decisions on your desk right now
2. Classify each using the Type 1-3 framework
3. Set concrete deadlines for each
4. For Type 2 and 3 decisions, determine your measurement criteria

One VP I worked with found that 80% of the decisions he was agonizing over were actually Type 3 – easily reversible with minimal consequences.

This realization alone freed up nearly 15 hours in his week.

The Ripple Effect

When you model effective decision-making, something remarkable happens:

Your leadership team starts to adopt the same approach. The bottlenecks that plagued your organization begin to dissolve.

Projects that once stalled now advance steadily. Opportunities that would have been missed are now captured.

Most importantly, your mental bandwidth clears up for the truly consequential decisions that deserve your full attention.

Question for reflection:

How many decisions are currently sitting on your desk? How many of them are truly Type 1?

Until next week, Shaun

P.S. Whenever you’re ready, here are 2 ways I can help you:

1. Want personalized guidance implementing the Decision Loop? My 1:1 Executive Coaching Program helps leaders like you build decisiveness across their entire leadership team. Click here to schedule a complimentary strategy session to see if we're a good fit.
2. Enjoy this newsletter? Hit the forward button and send it to 2-3 people in your network!